I've watched some of the new "Idol" shows (during commercial breaks from the other shows I really watch). I agree that Tyler is doing a good job. But, hey... It's fucking Steven Tyler, what else do we expect? The man is awesome!
But, as I watch him sitting there listening to these hopefuls audition... I can't help but feel sad, thinking about all the things he and Aerosmith could have done together. The "American Idol" season (from the auditions to awarding the winner) takes months! That's months of rocking that Tyler has robbed from his fan base. US!
And as the auditioners sing, Tyler joins in from time to time... as if he's yearning to grab the microphone himself. I caught one segment where Tyler sang along with a girl who was performing "Don't Want To Miss A Thing" from the judge's table. He sounded great! He should've been up there and she should've been listening and learning!
Tyler and the rest of Aerosmith aren't getting any younger, they're close to becoming senior citizens! There's no time to waste! I really hope Tyler gets back on the rock stage full time and leaves his judge's seat to someone like P. Diddy, whose 'musical abilities' won't be missed in his absence.
As far as the reality TV process goes... It ain't all bad. I watched "Rockstar: INXS" & "Rockstar: Supernova" and "Rock n Roll Fantasy Camp" on VH1 Classic. They were similarly formatted shows and each one was great. Like everything else, there's good and bad.